*

Recently, a Chinese court ruled that the four-petal flower device used by the tea brand Molly Tea (茉莉奶白) is confusingly similar to the well-known "Monogram Flower" trademark of French luxury brand Louis Vuitton (LV). The court ordered the brand to cease using the disputed logo and awarded RMB 10.3 million (approximately TWD 48.67 million) in damages.

The ruling has sparked widespread discussion. Some commentators argue that the four-petal flower motif originates from decorative elements commonly found in traditional architecture and lattice window designs, including the four-petal floral pattern and the “shidi” (persimmon calyx) motif, and therefore should not be monopolized by a single brand. From a trademark law perspective, however, the court's focus is not on who first created the design. Instead, the key issues are whether the sign has been lawfully registered as a trademark, whether it functions as an indicator of the source of goods or services, and whether its subsequent use is likely to cause confusion among relevant consumers as to the origin of those goods or services.

Notably, the judgment pointed out that Molly Tea had previously filed several similar device trademark applications in China, all of which were refused because of their similarity to LV's trademark. Despite these refusals, the company continued to use the disputed design on storefront signage, product packaging, and promotional materials across more than 2,000 stores in China (as of May 2026). This was one of the key factors leading the court to conclude that the infringement was intentional. In trademark practice, if an applicant has been informed through an official office action that its mark conflicts with an earlier trademark, yet continues to use the mark, that refusal may become an important consideration for a court when determining whether the applicant acted with intent to infringe.

Trademark protection extends beyond creative design—it also safeguards the distinctiveness and goodwill that a brand has built over time. When developing a logo, businesses should look beyond aesthetics by conducting comprehensive trademark clearance searches and risk assessments, and by securing trademark registration as early as possible. Taking these steps can help prevent costly infringement disputes after substantial resources have already been invested in building and growing a brand.

If you have any questions regarding trademark design, trademark clearance searches, or trademark registration, please feel free to contact Taiwan Advance Patent & Trademark Office.